The 42-hour problem: how fast do you really reply to inquiries?

Here is an uncomfortable experiment. Pick last Monday. Count the inquiries that arrived by call, WhatsApp, Instagram DM and your website form. Now write next to each one how long it took someone to reply, and who.

If you got stuck halfway through, you have just learned something useful. Most of us cannot answer that, and the customers know it.

The study everyone quotes

In 2011, researchers James Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington published a piece in Harvard Business Review called “The Short Life of Online Sales Leads.” They looked at about 1.25 million web leads sent to 29 consumer-facing and 13 business-to-business companies in the US. Their finding: firms that contacted a lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to have a meaningful conversation with a decision maker as firms that waited even one more hour. Against firms that waited a day or longer, the gap was more than sixty times.

A companion test sent a web inquiry to a large group of US companies. About 37% answered within an hour. Around a quarter took more than a day. Close to a quarter never answered at all. For the companies that did reply within 30 days, the average wait was 42 hours.

Two honest caveats. This is American data, and it is over a decade old. We are not claiming the exact multiples would repeat in Rawalpindi. The direction, though, is hard to argue with. A person who just filled in your form is thinking about you right now. By tomorrow they have called three other places.

What is different in Pakistan

A lot of inquiries here never touch a form. They arrive as a WhatsApp message, a voice note, a “price?” under an Instagram post, or a call to whichever number is on the shop sign. That makes the problem worse, not better. Four channels, three phones, and no single place where somebody can say “this one is mine.”

So the leak is rarely laziness. It is that nobody owns the inquiry. The salesperson thinks the owner replied. The owner thinks the salesperson did. The customer buys from whoever answered.

A one-week test you can run yourself

1. Mystery-shop yourself. From a number your team does not know, send your own business an inquiry on each channel at different times: morning, mid-afternoon, late evening, Friday.
2. Write down the clock. When it was sent, when the first human reply came, and whether that reply actually answered the question.
3. Look at the worst case, not the average. Your evening and weekend numbers are what your best-timed competitor will exploit.

Be ready to be unimpressed. That is the point.

Fixes that cost almost nothing

• Give every inquiry an owner and a status. “New”, “Replied”, “Quoted”, “Won”, “Lost.” A shared sheet is fine to begin with.
• Agree a reply window. Fifteen minutes in working hours is realistic for a first human response, even if it is only “got it, calling you at 4.”
• Cover the gaps. A saved WhatsApp Business greeting that sets expectations is better than silence. It is not a substitute for a person, and customers can tell.
• Review the lost ones weekly. Ten minutes, every Monday. Most patterns jump out quickly.

When a spreadsheet stops working

A sheet holds up until more than one person edits it, or inquiries come from more than two places. After that you want something that captures every inquiry in one pipeline, nudges whoever is late, and shows you the week at a glance. That is what our inquiry management service is for, and WhatsApp automation handles the routine first replies so your team can spend its time on real conversations.

If you run ads, our performance marketing work is judged on leads that got a reply and became a customer, not on clicks. Otherwise the number you report is a vanity number.

Sources

• Oldroyd, McElheran and Elkington, “The Short Life of Online Sales Leads,” Harvard Business Review, 2011. Figures here are as quoted in summaries by CustomerThink and CrankWheel. The study is US-based and from 2011.

Back to Insights